On a Friday in March, Osteria Lume lost three tables of six in one evening. Eighteen covers, in a 48-cover room, on the busiest night of the week. Inês Carvalho, who owns the place, remembers the number because she wrote it on the back of the order pad: 612 € of food that never left the walk-in.
Her first idea was the one most owners have: ask every guest for a card, and charge anyone who doesn't come. She tried it for two weeks. Online bookings for two dropped by a fifth. Couples, it turned out, would rather call a place that didn't ask.
Who actually doesn't show up
When we looked at Osteria Lume's bookings from the year before, the pattern was plain. Tables of two almost always came. The big tables were the problem: they are booked weeks ahead, by one person, for a group that hasn't fully agreed yet.
| Party size | Bookings | No-shows | Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 guests | 2,104 | 42 | 2.0% |
| 3–5 guests | 1,317 | 71 | 5.4% |
| 6 guests and up | 388 | 54 | 13.9% |
One booking in ten was for six or more. Those bookings were behind more than a third of the empty chairs.
The rule: six and up, ten euros a guest
So Inês asked for a deposit only from six guests up, at 10 € per person. The deposit comes off the bill, which matters more than it sounds: for a group that shows up, it costs nothing. It only costs the table that doesn't.
- Say it before the form. The booking page shows the deposit as soon as someone picks six guests, not on the last step.
- Charge late, refund fast. Mesa charges 15 minutes after the booking time. If the group calls from the car, the host refunds in one tap.
- Write a human sentence. Inês's confirmation reads: "We hold the big table for you and turn other guests away. The deposit is how we know you are coming."
What changed
−31%
no-shows across the room
−68%
no-shows at tables of six and up
+3%
online bookings for two
The surprise was the phone. Groups that used to book by calling now book online, because the deposit made the booking feel real to them too. Inês's staff answer the phone about 40 times fewer a week.
“I don't want to punish anyone. I want the six people who said they'd come to come. Ten euros does that better than a speech.”
If you try it tomorrow
- Export last year's bookings and count no-shows by party size. If big tables aren't your problem, a deposit won't fix it.
- Start at the size where the rate jumps, not at a round number.
- Keep the deposit small enough that nobody argues. Most rooms land between 10 € and 20 € a guest.
- Look again after eight Fridays, not after one.